Lynn Guyer, Newly Appointed Warden State of Montana Prison, Shocking Support of Bizarre Judge

Lynn Guyer was recently appointed Warden of the Montana State Prison.  The appointment was made by Reginald Michael, Director of the Montana Department of Corrections.  Guyer’s support of Idaho Judge Randy Stoker is so shocking and so outside of Montana values.  Read the entire blog about this 14 year old rape victim that was impregnated by her rapist and you decide if Guyer’s support of Judge Stoker is something you can support.  Your tax money is supporting these values.

01/14/2018 - Lynn Guyer
I first met Judge Stoker in 1996 while I was District Manager of Probation/Parole in Twin Falls. I found him to be a very honorable man. He always kept a balance with what was best for society, the victim and the offender in mind when determining his decisions. Lynn Guyer, Warden Retired, North Idaho Correctional Institution.

Idaho judge says rape is 'a direct consequence of the social media system.' After issuing an unusual probation sentence for a man who raped a 14-year-old girl, Judge Randy J Stoker delivered a sermon on modern-day morality.

An Idaho judge who said a man who raped a 14-year-old girl could be released on probation if he agreed not to have sex outside of wedlock also linked the case to a breakdown of morality in the social media age, adding: If I had my way, I would eliminate the internet.

The unusual requirement that a convict remain celibate as a condition of probation received widespread attention this week, after segments of Judge Randy J Stokers ruling were made public.

I will tell you, sir, that if you are ever placed on probation to this court, a condition of that probation will be you will not have sexual relations with anyone other than who you are married to, if you're married, period, the Twin Falls district judge said.

However, additional details of the judges ruling, contained in a transcript of the hearing obtained by the Guardian, reveal how Stoker delivered what amounts to a sermon on modern-day morality in which he connected the 14-year-old victim's rape to the social media system.

The extramarital celibacy requirement is highly unusual but has some statutory basis in conservative Idaho, where premarital sex is still technically a crime, although the statute banning fornication is rarely if ever enforced.

Twin Falls prosecuting attorney Grant P Loebs said the sex offenders compliance with the no-sex rule would be tested via polygraph. "The probation officer whose job it is to make sure you're not a threat to the community will ask you ... have you been doing this or this or this?" he said. "That's the way those conditions are checked. Not by spying on someone."

Stoker said in court that he could have sentenced Cody D Herrera to life in prison for raping the 14-year-old girl in 2015. Instead, he sent the 20-year-old to a treatment program run by the Idaho prison system. If Herrera completes the program within a year, he will be placed on probation.

But if he violates the conditions of his probation, Stoker said, he will be sentenced to as much as 15 years in prison.

In handing down his striking judgement last month, Stoker imposed the additional condition of celibacy outside of marriage, and also railed against what he suggested was today's hook-up culture. He questioned Herrera's level of remorse and noted the young mans proclivities, a taste for pornography, an astounding number of partners, and fantasies of sex with a 13-year-old girl.

Modern-day technology, he added, was at fault.

I think it is a direct consequence of the social media system that we have in this country, Stoker continued. I can't tell you how many times I have seen these cases: How did this happen? Well, I met somebody on social media.

Stoker conceded that Snapchat, Facebook, Instagram and other sites might not be the direct cause of all the sexual assault cases he has presided over in the deeply conservative Gem State. But he said the vast majority of such cases originate online.

I can't change that, he said. If I had my way, I would eliminate the internet, and we'd all have better lives. But I can't do that either. It also says something about, I guess, the level of morality in this country. I can't change morality. People are going to do what they're going to do.

According to court documents, Herrera and the victim met in 2014. He was 17 at the time. The girl told him she was 16. They hung out with friends, went to the mall, and communicated via Facebook. But when her mother found out about the relationship, she tried to put a stop to it.

The mother called Herrera and Herrera's mother. She explained that her child was only 14, too young to have a boyfriend. But Herrera and the girl continued their online relationship.

On 2 March 2015, Herrera snuck into the girls bedroom, ostensibly to watch a movie with her. He began to fondle the girl. She asked him to stop. He then raped her without wearing a condom.

Not long after, according to the affidavit of Twin Falls police detective Benjamin Mittelstadt, Herrera heard a rumor that the girl was pregnant. He called her mother to find out, in a conversation that was later downloaded from the woman's phone.

During this conversation Mr Herrera admitted to knowing that [the girl] was underage, Mittelstadt said, and stated he did not want to be stuck behind bars being raped and stabbed for what had happened.

The girls mother told Stoker in the Twin Falls courtroom that her family fell prey to a manipulative predator. Herrera did not just rape her daughter, the woman said, but he also harassed and threatened the young girl and her friends and relatives.

It was his intent from the beginning to take what he wanted from my 14-year-old child, her virginity, and he stayed around until he got it from her, she told Stoker. Cody will never understand what he has done to our family. Cody robbed her of her innocence. He destroyed the child left in her. This can never be returned.

Dan Brown, Herrera's defense attorney, told Stoker that his client comes before this court young and somewhat naive in many respects. His fondness for pornography might be unsavory, Brown said, but it certainly hasn't hurt anyone.

Herrera pleaded guilty to one felony count of rape. By his own admission, the judge said, Herrera had 34 sexual encounters with separate individuals while still in his teens and his attitude was, well, I'm going to use young children for sexual gratification.

I have never, never seen that level of sexual activity in a 19-year-old, in this court system, and I've been doing this for 15, 16 years, Stoker said. My view of life is that what you do in the past is a good indication of what you're going to do in the future.

01/14/2018 - Lynn Guyer
I first met Judge Stoker in 1996 while I was District Manager of Probation/Parole in Twin Falls. I found him to be a very honorable man. He always kept a balance with what was best for society, the victim and the offender in mind when determining his decisions. Lynn Guyer, Warden Retired, North Idaho Correctional Institution.

A little 14 year old girl is raped and impregnated.  The judge says it is the fault of social media and sentences the sex offender to a celibate probation.  The sex offender can only have sex with his wife, if he is married.  Warden Lynn Guyer says the judge is a very honorable man and supports Judge Stoker stating that a celibate probation for a sex offender is what is best for society.

There isn't anymore I can say here that isn't already here.  Do you support the appointment of Lynn Guyer as Warden of the Montana State Prison?




 

Montana Dept of Corrections and Community Counseling and Correctional Services Antiquated Treatment

Community Counseling and Correctional Services (CCCS) Inc is a not for profit, private correctional facility in Butte that contracts with the Montana Department of Corrections (MDOC) to incarcerate and provide treatment for adult offenders.  CCCS Inc contracts with MDOC to provide addiction treatment at WATCH, the men’s program at Warm Springs and Watche, the women’s program in Glendive.

The men's WATCH program has a capacity of 115 individuals.  CCCS Inc contracts with the Montana Department of Corrections for a per diem daily rate of $63.69.  The total daily per diem rate is $7324.35.  The treatment program lasts for 6 months or 180 days.  The total cost of treatment for 115 individuals for 6 months is $1,318,383.00.

The women's WATCHe program has a capacity of 50 individuals.  CCCS Inc contracts with the Montana Department of Corrections for a per diem daily rate of $103.62.  The total daily per diem rate is $5181.00.  The treatment lasts for 6 months or 180 days.  The total cost of treatment for 50 individuals for 6 months is $932,580.00.

The total cost for 6 months of treatment for WATCH and WATCHe is $2,250,963.00.

The 2017 Legislature changed state law concerning treatment programs for people convicted of fourth or subsequent DUI.  Whereas people convicted of a fourth or more felony DUI charge were previously required to either serve prison time or complete WATCh’s in-patient treatment, House Bill 133, a sweeping sentencing-reform bill passed last year, contains a provision that allows them to be sentenced to an appropriate treatment court program instead, which Mike Thatcher (CEO of CCCS Inc) finds baffling.

Baffling?  Participants in treatment court programs are enrolled for 12 - 18 months at a cost of $4000.00 per offender.  If all 165 WATCH's participants were treated in treatment court programs the total cost would be $660,000.00 for 12 months of treatment vs the $2,250,963.00 for 6 months of treatment through the CCCS Inc WATCH programs.  In treatment court the offender has access to a social worker, an addiction counselor, a probation officer and a public attorney.  They are required to find their own housing, get a job, pay taxes and are at home with their children rather than the children being farmed out to foster care or elderly grandparents.  The job requirements for CCCS Inc is a high school diploma or GED vs a social worker, addiction counselor, a probation officer and a public attorney, all educated professionals.

Mike Thatcher and the Montana Department of Corrections operates on an antiquated belief system.  Evidence-based practices (this is a popular phrase now used in the correctional system) shows that addictions are the result of early childhood trauma.  Mike Thatcher believes Montanans "advocate that people should be completing WATCh as a ‘pound of flesh.’”

I believe that most Montanans advocate for the ability to provide housing, food, education and opportunities for their families.  The antiquated "pound of flesh" phrase comes from Shylock, a character in the play The Merchant of Venice by William Shakespeare. He is a Jewish money-lender who lends money to Antonio. When Antonio is unable to pay the money back, Shylock says he has the right to cut a pound of flesh from Antonio's body. I don't believe that Montanans want to cut flesh from the bodies of victims of childhood trauma. 

With a salary of a quarter of a million dollars a year, Mike Thatcher can afford a Shakespearean belief of cutting the flesh from trauma victims.  Other Montanans cannot afford the huge tax burden of supporting CCCS Inc and the Montana Department of Corrections antiquated belief system.  William Shakespeare died 400 years ago.  In 400 years we have evolved to evidence-based practices for treating early childhood trauma.  That evidence-based practice does not include cutting flesh from people.

Montanans advocate for improving the lives of their families.  Unnecessary tax burdens of millions of dollars does not improve the lives of Montana tax payers, it only improves the bank balances of CCCS Inc and the political position of the Montana Department of Corrections.

Are you still baffled Mike Thatcher (CEO of CCCS Inc) and Reginald Michael (Director of MDOC)?


Private Corrections in Montana, CCCS Inc, The Bottomless Money Pit

CCCS Inc, (Community, Counseling and Corrections) in Butte Mt is also known as Butte Pre-Release and Women’s Transitional Center.  CCCS Inc opened its doors December 24, 1983, as a private contract correctional facility.  In 2002, CCCS Inc. successfully contracted with the Federal Bureau of Prisons to design, build and operate a 60-bed secure juvenile correction facility at Galen MT.  The name of the juvenile center at Galen was  Reintegrating Youthful Offenders (RYO).  The total cost of the project was 9.6 million dollars.

CCCS Inc charged a daily per diem rate of $235.75 for each incarcerated youth.  The facility operated for 12 years. $235.75 daily per diem X 60 beds = $14,145.00 per day. $14,145.00 X 365 days = $5,162,925.00 per year.  $5,162,925.00 X 12 years = $61,955,100.  The total cost of the project to CCCS Inc was 9.6 million dollars.  CCCS Inc. was paid $62 million dollars for operating Reintegrating Youthful Offenders.  CCCS Inc is a private contract prison facility.

Mike Thatcher, CEO of CCCS, said placement of offenders at the Reintegrating Youthful Offenders (RYO) facility, primarily serves the Federal Bureau of Prisons, the U.S. Marshal’s Service and Native American reservations across Montana. 

Mike Thatcher said "the trend is to more alternative placements. I've been in this business 35 years and I've seen a lot of trends."  He said it's "one of the crappiest things" he's experienced in his career.  

Is it wise to send our children to a facility where it is unlikely that their parents or other significant adults in their lives will be able to have visitation with them and be involved in their intervention/treatment programs? How do Native Americans travel from far away reservations to Galen MT to be involved in their child's recovery?  To Mike Thatcher the consideration of treating children in alternative placements closer to home is "one the crappiest things" he's experienced in his career.  Mike Thatcher makes a salary of over one quarter of a million dollars a year.  His private contract youth correctional facility has garnered $62,000,000.00.  And so CCCS Inc closes RYO because of the "crappy decision" to treat children closer to their families. Don't be too concerned for Mike Thatcher and CCCS Inc because they found a deep pocket and silver lining called the State Of Montana.

Montana Gov. Steve Bullock’s office announced that the state would lease the RYO facility and operate it as a facility for those committed to the currently critically overcrowded Montana State Hospital at Warm Springs through the criminal justice system. 

 Montana officials signed a 19-year lease at the 38,000-square-foot former federal juvenile placement facility in Galen – terms that squeaked just under square footage and lease term requirements that would have triggered mandatory legislative review of the deal.
There was no competitive bidding process to award the Galen lease. In fact, officials said they didn’t even look at potential alternatives to the $1.2 million annual agreement.

That's how the state’s newest landlord became Community Counseling and Correctional Services – a Butte-based nonprofit that employs Brandie Villa, a top company accountant and the wife of Governor’s Office Budget Director Dan Villa.

The State of Montana is obligated to CCCS Inc for a 19 year lease that totals $22,800,000.00.  CCCS Inc has managed to turn one private contract correctional facility costing $9.6 million into a facility that has garnered taxpayer funds of $84.8 million.  

This is the profit in non profit private corrections in Montana.  To quote Mike Thatcher "this is one of the crappiest things" I've seen.




	

Oh The Tangled Webs We Weave – Montana Board of Pardons and Parole

Montana Headlines: Montana’s new parole board is granting inmates’ release sooner after major changes made in 2017… according to data released by the Criminal Justice Oversight Council.  The quicker parole process owes to changes made during the 2017 Legislature.

The Montana Board of Pardons and Parole transitioned from a seven member volunteer board to a five member board at a cost of one half million dollars a year to the tax payers of Montana.  Board member Annette Carter made some very rosy statistics and data to the Criminal Justice Oversight Council.  Shall we see what the real data is?  

Data under the previous volunteer board:
January, 2017:  The Board made final dispositions on 246 matters.  The Board granted 59 paroles.  This is a 24% parole rate.

February, 2017: The Board made final dispositions on 252 matters.  The Board granted 61 paroles.  This is a 24% parole rate.

March, 2017:  The Board made final dispositions on 285 matters.  The Board granted 81 paroles.  This is a 28% parole rate.

The average parole rate under the old volunteer board for January, February and March 2017 is 25%.

Data under the new one half million dollar a year board:
January, 2018:  The Board made final dispositions on 278 matters.  The Board granted 70 paroles.  This is a 25% parole rate.

February, 2018:  The Board made final dispositions on 284 matters.  The Board granted 77 paroles.  This is a 27% parole rate.

March, 2018:  The Board made final dispositions on 331 matters.  The Board granted 88 paroles.  This is a 27% parole rate.

The average parole rate under the new one half million dollar a year board for January, February and March 2018 is 26%.  

For one half million dollars a year the State of Montana is getting a 1% increase in paroles granted.

There was broad bipartisan legislative support for the changes to the parole board.  The bill passed 97-3 in the House and 47-3 in the Senate. Only six people were against the huge financial expenditures for a 1% increase in granted paroles.  

I am not seeing the rosy picture Annette Carter presented to the Criminal Justice Oversight Committee.  Data can be skewed in many ways to present brilliant work and great results. Wording of the data can skew the true meaning. The data provided to the Oversight Committee was for the one month of April 2018.  The Board simply schedules in the month of April everyone they know they are going to parole.  That would surely skew the great results of the Board.  

Oh the tangled webs we weave when first we practice to deceive.  Look at all the data before pronouncing the brilliant success of the Montana Board of Pardons and Parole.  The new board achieved a 1% increase in parole over the old board.







State of Montana Board of Pardons and Parole – The Insanity Of The Group

In individuals, insanity is rare; but in groups, parties, nations and epochs, it is the rule.  Friedrich Nietzsche.  And so the insanity continues in the group known as The Montana Board of Pardons and Parole.

July 2017, a new Montana Board of Pardons and Parole was created under Senate Bill 64.  The Board went from a volunteer board to a five member board costing the state tax payers almost 1/2 a million dollars a year.  The board was created to address stability, accountability, transparency and arbitrary decisions, and to develop an offender reentry and risk  assessment.

Stability:  After less than one year since the board was created there has been a 40% turnover rate in board members.  Determining the valuation of a privately held company, a 40% employee turnover rate in less than one year would greatly devalue the effectiveness and stability of the company.  Montana tax payers should rate the stability of the Board of Pardons and Parole an F for failure of stability.

Accountability:  The Montana Board of Pardons and Parole (BOPP) fails to provide to offenders, formulas used to calculate their risk and assessment scores prior to parole hearings, prejudicing the inmates right to prepare for parole hearings. BOPP does not provide the criteria or methods used to complete the Montana Reentry Risk Assessment even after the inmate pays the required fee of $40.00 to obtain the information. Portions of parole packets have missing or incomplete psychological or cognitive evaluations.  Per Montana Statutes ARM 20.25.103(11) Montana tax payers should rate The Montana Board of Pardons and Parole an F for accountability for failure to abide by ARM 20.25.103(11) An offender may request to view his/her individual parole file by making a request in writing. Board staff will provide the offender an opportunity to inspect the file except for information deemed confidential.  

Montana tax payers should rate the Montana Board of Pardons and Parole an F for accountability for failure to abide by MCA 2-4-103. Rules and statements to be made available to public. (1) Each agency shall:(a) make available for public inspection all rules and all other written statements of policy or interpretations formulated, adopted, or used by the agency in the discharge of its functions;(b) upon request of any person, provide a copy of any rule.(2) Unless otherwise provided by statute, an agency may require the payment of the cost of providing such copies.(3) No agency rule is valid or effective against any person or party whose rights have been substantially prejudiced by an agency's failure to comply with the public inspection requirement herein.

Transparency and arbitrary decisions:  Under the newly configured Montana Board of Pardons and Parole all proceedings are to be video taped and audio tape recorded.  The Montana Board of Pardons and Parole routinely allow victim witnesses to testify before the inmates' scheduled parole hearing.  The prospective parolee and the parolee's attorney are precluded from attending the beginning of the hearing or during the testimony of the victim witness.  MCA 2-3-203(3) The presiding officer of any meeting may close the meeting during the time the discussion relates to a matter of individual privacy and then if and only if the presiding officer determines that the demands of individual privacy clearly exceed the merits of public disclosure. The right of individual privacy may be waived by the individual about whom the discussion pertains and, in that event, the meeting must be open. At no time during these parole hearings does the record or recordings of the hearings indicate the Parole Board issued any findings that the victim witnesses individual privacy clearly exceeds the merits of public disclosure.  Parole Board members, without explanation or rulings, arbitrarily decide what is individual privacy.  Without any explanation to the prospective parolee the BOPP simply precludes that testimony from the record.  When counsel for the prospective parolee requests recordings of the private hearings the attorney is provided with blank and silent tape recordings of the beginning of the hearing.  The Board enters closed executive hearings with arbitrarily decided findings in violation of ARM 20.25.103 DISSEMINATION OF INFORMATION(1) As a public agency, all board records including any audio/video recordings are public. All board records are subject to disclosure except in cases in which the individual right of privacy clearly exceeds the merits of public disclosure, and in cases in which statute makes the record confidential.(7) Whenever a crime victim asserts an individual privacy interest, the board may not disseminate to the public the name, address, telephone number, or place of employment of the victim or a member of the victim's family unless otherwise required by law.  The Montana Board of Pardons and Parole cannot withhold from public view any more information than is required to protect an individual interest which is limited to name, address, phone number, place of employment or victim family member.  Yet the Montana Board of Pardons and Parole arbitrarily decides to provide  prospective parolee's attorneys with blank and silent audio recordings of the entire closed executive meeting.  Montana tax payers should rate The Montana Board of Pardons and Parole an F for failure to maintain transparency in executive meetings and an F for arbitrary decision making.

Development of Montana Offender Reentry and Risk Management (MORRA):  The parole board was required to create structured parole guidelines that are based on research and evidence-based practices. These guidelines will mandate that when making a release decision, the parole board consider a person’s risk level as determined by the Montana Offender Reentry Risk Assessment tool, MORRA.  MORRA is a gender-neutral standardized and validated evidence-based instrument used to assess the probability of an offender recidivating and to identify risk factors and criminogenic needs to guide and prioritize appropriate programming.  Morra is gender-neutral standardized guidelines. This is what MORRA encompasses.  The Community Supervision Screening tool is used for both male and female offenders as part of the pre-sentence investigation.  The Community Supervision Tool is used for male offenders.  The Prison Intake Tool is used for male offenders.  The Prison Screening tool is used for male offenders.  The Reentry tool is used for male offenders.  The Supplemental Reentry Tool focuses on male offenders.  The newly configured Montana Board of Pardons and Parole was tasked with the creation of  mandated structured parole guidelines and reentry programs.  All the guidelines the BOPP implemented are for male offender programming for successful reentry.  At Parole hearings the female offenders are simply screened for Pre-Release programs.  There is no programming implemented for successful female reentry.   Montana tax payers should rate The Montana Board of Pardons and Parole an F for failing to implement tools to assist female offenders with Offender Reentry and Risk Management tools.  

The cornerstone and linchpin for Montana correctional reform is based on the newly formed Montana Board of Pardons and Parole.  Montana tax payers are paying the board members one half of a million dollars a year to be the linchpin and cornerstone for the new reformation of criminal justice.

For one half of a million dollars a year, this is what Montana tax payers are getting:

STABILITY ------------- F FOR FAILURE
ACCOUNTABILITY -------- F FOR FAILURE
TRANSPARENCY AND
  ARBITRARY DECISIONS - F FOR FAILURE
DEVELOPMENT OF MONTANA
  OFFENDER REENTRY AND
  RISK MANAGEMENT ----- F FOR FAILURE

The famous German philosopher, Friedrich Nietzsche, was correct when he said insanity in groups is the rule.
  

 

Sam McCormack and Reed Scott, Investigators’ Lies That Falsely Convict

January 12, 1994, Donna Meagher was kidnapped in Montana City MT and brutally murdered west of Helena MT.  Donna’s family will never recover from the wounds left from this tragedy.  Day turns to night and into day again.  The wounds never heal.  Winter turns to spring, flowers bloom and the sun shines.  The wounds never heal.

Lewis and Clark County Detective Sam McCormack and State Investigator Reed Scott investigated the crime, interviewed witnesses and collected evidence for probable cause to file criminal charges.  Once criminal charges are filed the defendant is presumed guilty whether the evidence is true or not.  After being incarcerated for 24 years new evidence has emerged that may exonerate the men Sam McCormack and Reed Scott incarcerated.  Lewis and Clark County Attorney Leo Gallagher had this to say about the investigation of Sam McCormack and Reed Scott.

County Attorney Leo Gallagher said statements Freddie Lawrence made to authorities were obtained involuntarily and in violation of Miranda.  Gallagher stated that "evidence" obtained by Sam McCormack and Reed Scott should be viewed with distrust.  Leo Gallagher is an attorney and prosecutor.  It is a violation of ethics to lie.

County Attorney Leo Gallagher says that Investigator Reed Scott threatened to charge Freddie Lawrence with perjury and obstruction of justice if Lawrence attempted to correct the statements that were involuntarily obtained.  The same statements that should be viewed with distrust.

County Attorney Leo Gallagher says that Officers Sam McCormack and Reed Scott coerced Freddie Lawrence into talking using impermissible practices including lengthy interrogations, "good cop/bad cop" techniques, misrepresenting the officers intent, feigned concern for his family, threats to take his family away and threats of the death penalty.  Once again remember Leo Gallagher states that evidence and statements collected by Sam McCormack and Reed Scott should be viewed with distrust.  

 Mary Jenkins, wife of Defendant Paul Jenkins, was a star witness for Sam McCormack and Reed Scott for probable cause to file criminal charges.  Leo Gallagher made the following statements about Mary Jenkins:  "Mary suffers from memory lapses much more acute and frequent than the average person.  She was diagnosed with a condition of dementia, most likely of the Alzheimer's type."  Leo Gallagher states concerns that despite this she was determined competent to testify.  County Attorney Leo Gallagher actually says that Mary's testimony violated the defendants Sixth Amendment right to confrontation because her statements were so inconsistent that there was no ability for the defendant to cross-examine.  However at this point that is irrelevant because the evidence collected was already used for the probable cause to file criminal charges. Evidence and statements that should be viewed with distrust.  

New DNA evidence exists that shows the murder was committed by David Wayne Nelson.  David Nelson is currently serving a prison sentence for killing two people after the conviction of Freddie Lawrence and Paul Jenkins.  A conviction obtained by Detective Sam McCormack and Investigator Reed Scott.  A conviction that Lewis and Clark County Attorney Leo Gallagher says should be viewed with distrust.

 

Implosion Of The Montana Department of Corrections

In January, 2018 the Montana Law and Justice Interim Committee met in Helena.  The meeting was particularly interesting in that a glaring deficiency was apparent.  Unless Governor Steve Bullock and Department of Corrections Director Reginald Michael are truly behind the Committee it will fail and, unfortunately, it has been designed to fail.  The implosion of the Montana Department of Corrections began in 2014 and continues today.  Governor Bullock and previous Corrections Director Mike Batista and Bureau Chief Ron Alsbury are fully responsible.

Montana’s prisons are over capacity. The prison population increased 11 percent between FY2008 and FY2015 and is projected to continue to grow 13
percent by FY2023, requiring at least $51 million in new spending for contract prison beds.

Corrections in Montana is big business.  Really big business.  Private Corrections in Montana is really big business.  State run corrections in Montana is really big business.

By Peter Wagner and Bernadette Rabuy

January 25, 2017

 

  • Graph showing the $182 billion system of mass incarceration and the relative size of its sub-parts from policing, to courts to private companies. Private prisons are a very small part of the total.
Governor Bullock is term limited from being Governor for another term in Montana.  His sights are set on a national campaign.  National political campaigns are not funded by individual felons from Montana.  They are funded by big business.  This is where the implosion began and how it continues today.

In July 2014 Director Mike Batista and Bureau Chief Ron Alsbury began discussing reorganization of the Adult Community Corrections Division and changes to the sanctions grid.  The sanctions grid determines the probation/parole status of offenders and what punishments are exacted for violations, including minor and technical infractions.  The following grid was established.  Click on link below to view grid.

sj3-sanctions-flow-chart

October 9, 2014 Department of Corrections personnel received an email from Dave Armstrong, Administrator of Alternatives Inc, a private contract pre-release center, which is known as Alpha House for men and Passages for women. "So besides Cr'ing (conditional release) everyone in jail, what else?  What should we expect from the P&P grid, will be asked to hang onto drug and alcohol users?"

Probation/Parole offenders that are under normal supervision are sanctioned to jail by court authority.  Probation/Parole offenders on conditional release, under the new grid, will be sanctioned by probation/parole officers to private contract facilities without having to file with the court.  There is no money in corrections for offenders sitting in jail. There is big money for offenders sanctioned to private facilities.  Under the P&P grid all sanctions for conditional release will be made to private contract facilities without the need for interventions and court action. Put everyone sitting in jail on conditional release then probation/parole does not need to go through interventions they simply go straight to private incarceration. The plan is now in place for big business.

September 16, 2014 at a DOC meeting it was revealed that one DOC employee had a meeting with Mike Thatcher, CEO of Butte Pre-release, where it was revealed that Governor Bullock had called Mike Thatcher to his office and Governor Bullock told him to keep his mouth shut about DOC issues and to back off during the legislative session.  Without revealing his plan to Mike Thatcher Governor Bullock did not want Thatcher to disrupt his plans to increase private contractor beds to increase population in private facilities.  The plan for big business.

September 30, 2104 at a meeting with DOC personnel, concerns were expressed that the contract with PEW Charitable Trust and Dennis Schranz was "shady and would bite us in the ass."  Concern was also expressed that there was no procurement for the PEW contract and that personnel and contractors would be watching for the contract to be posted to a department or state website.  The PEW Charitable Trust is a consulting firm that was hired to assist the Montana Law and Justice Interim Committee to plan and reform criminal justice and sentencing.  The Pew Charitable Trust was hired to reduce the need for more private contract beds while Governor Bullock, Mike Batista and Ron Alsbury's plan was to increase private contract beds by sanctioning probation/parolees to conditional release, bypassing interventions and sanctioning offenders directly to contract beds.

The Law and Justice Interim Committee is being directed by The Pew Charitable Trust with a contract that was not put through the State of Montana procurement process.  The intent of the Committee is to reduce jail, prison and private contract incarceration.  Unbeknownst to the Law and Justice Committee, the Governor and the Director of the Montana Department of Corrections are acting in a complete opposite direction.  Big business requires the incarceration of individuals and Governor Bullock needs the backing of big business.  This includes corrections agencies both public and private, employees and their big business unions, health care, construction, food, utilities, clothing, phone companies, judges, prosecutors, public defenders, police and their unions, commissary and the list goes on for big business.  

The Law and Justice Interim Committee meets and listens to attractive people with agenda's purporting the good work they are doing to reduce jail, prison and private incarceration.  They tour facilities and have inmates smile at them for the good work they are attempting to do.  The real question they need to ask is how many probation/parolees are conditionally released from jails and then sanctioned to private contract facilities and prisons because under the P&P grid those on conditional release do not need to go through the intervention and court process.  They are sanctioned to incarceration because the probation and parole officers no longer have to file with the court to sanction them.  The incarceration rates continue to rise because Governor Bullock's plan undermines the work of the Committee and they don't have a clue what is really happening.

Governor Bullock needs big business to finance his national campaign.  The next question is where does the new Montana Director of Corrections Reginald Michael stand?  He was hand picked by Governor Bullock. Does he stand with Governor Bullock and the Montana Department of Corrections undermining the work of the Committee or does he stand with the Law and Justice Interim Committee?  


 
 

 

Set Free Our Wrongfully Imprisoned MT Native Americans – Radical Mormon Theology

October 2016, Ammon and Ryan Bundy were acquitted of all federal charges in the “Oregon Standoff”, the armed occupation of the Malheur National Wildlife Refuge.

April 24, 2017, I posted Oregon Militiamen, Mormonism and  Our Public Schools.  I am reposting this blog following the comments of Ryan Bundy, January 8, 2018.

January 8, 2018, federal charges are dismissed against Cliven Bundy, Ryan Bundy and Ammon Bundy in the Nevada standoff.

Ryan Bundy, who represented himself in both Oregon and Nevada, told reporters that the family’s decision to stand up against what they saw as federal tyranny was informed by their belief in the scripture of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, particularly the “white horse prophecy,” which contends that LDS followers will be the final defenders of the U.S. Constitution. The LDS church has continually condemned the actions of the Bundy family and says that the white horse prophecy is not accepted doctrine and more akin to conspiracy theory.

But on Wednesday, Ryan Bundy spoke of the prophecy as truth: “Joseph Smith prophesied that the Constitution would at some point hang as if it were by a thread,” he said. “Put it this way: Whether the church calls it doctrine or not, we’ve got quotes from several prophets reiterating that. . . . I take the words of the prophets both modern and previous ones seriously.”

Ryan Bundy’s quote taken from the The Washington Post.

This blog was posted April 24, 2017, about 8 months before Ryan Bundy’s comments to the Washington Post.  Helenawinds.com

A cautionary tale for parents and students of Montana Public Schools.  Are your children being programmed to radical Mormon (Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints) theology?  Are your children coming home with certain innocent key phrases that you don’t even pay attention to?  Here are some key phrases you should be tuning into and why they are steeped in radical Mormon theology taught in your schools to your children.

1) The White Horse (refers to the White Horse Prophecy)
2) The Constitution is hanging by a thread.(Precursor for the White Horse)
Variations:1) Shredding the Constitution 2) Tramping on liberties
                    3) Betraying the Founders
3) Secret Combinations (Mormon euphemism for Satanic conspirators)
4) National Center for Constitutional Studies

Oregon Militiamen LaVoy Fincum, Ammon Bundy and Ryan Bundy have at least four things in common. They are devout members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints (Mormons), they believe(d) in the White Horse Prophecy, they believe(d)  the United States Government was comprised of secret combinations and they all conspicuously carried pocket copies of the Constitution printed by the National Center for Constitutional Studies. Ammon and Ryan’s father, Clive Bundy, was not at the Oregon occupation but he shared the same beliefs during the Nevada standoff with the government and his family.

The nation misunderstood the real meaning behind the standoff.  The White Horse Prophecy, first attributed to the Mormon Prophet, Joseph Smith, reveals “the time would come when the Constitution and the country would be in danger of an overthrow and if the Constitution be saved at all, it will be by the elders of this Church.”  

LaVoy Fincum, Clive Bundy, Ammon Bundy, and Ryan Bundy were attempting to bring forth the White Horse Prophecy and, being Elders of the Mormon Church, were going to save the Constitution from the secret combinations of the Government.  Fincum made references to “The Title of Liberty” a story from the Book of Mormon in which the Nephites had to stand and fight for their liberty, religion and land.  Another Mormon occupier, Dylan Anderson, used Captain Moroni (the last remaining Nephite who hid the golden plates for Joseph Smith to find and translate the Book of Mormon) as his alias when talking to reporters.

Before the occupation Ammon Bundy said the constitution was “hanging by a thread” an allusion to the White Horse Prophecy, wherein Mormons would have to come forth and save the Constitution.  Glenn Beck and Senator Orin Hatch are often heard sending this coded message.  Most Americans that have heard this think of it as just another overblown commentary and think nothing of it.  To those familiar with the White Horse Prophecy, it is an unmistakable signal.  It is the calling to Mormon Elders to come forth and save the Constitution.

W. Cleon Skousen wrote the pocket constitution (see the cover page at the top of this post.)  This interpretation of the constitution is a fraudulent, pseudo-historical pamphlet.  Skousen believed the Constitution was based on a Christian theocracy and the Federal Government had no authority.  He drew his inspiration from the John Birch Society that was co-founded by the Koch brother’s father.  Throughout the pamphlet, in the margins, is Mormon theocracy and in coded language calling forth the Mormon Elders to save this land and Constitution.  The Center for Constitutional Studies was founded by Mormons and is headquartered in Idaho,

Florida distributed over 80,000 copies of this pseudo constitution to school age children before the Tampa Bay Times clued them into the notes and annotations by Skousen,

Sit down with your children.  Ask them if they have heard any of the phrases mentioned.  Check their school and homework and see if any of the phrases are included in the work.  If your child comes home with a pocket constitution with the picture shown at the beginning of this post go immediately to your school board.  Don’t let secret coded radical Mormon theology influence your children.

The nation got it wrong once, the standoffs were not about grazing rights, and federal overreach.  They were coded messages to the Elders of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints to fulfill the White Horse Prophecy.  Don’t let that misunderstanding reach into the classroom.

End of blog.

 Now you understand I know what I'm talking about.  Please read the following archived blogs:
February 2. 2017. Was Justice Delivered?
March 4, 2017. Montana Department of Corrections - A Shameful Failure.
March 15, 2017. Montana Department of Corrections Sin of Dark Skin.

The Federal Government spent millions and millions of dollars in the costs of standoffs, surveillance, investigations and prosecutions not because of states rights but, in Ryan Bundy's own words, pursuing radical Mormon Theology.  LaVoy Fincum was killed not because of states rights but because of Mormon Theology.  The Montana Department of Corrections has spent millions of dollars in the revocation of probation and parole of Native Americans not because of wrongs committed but because of Mormon Theology.  How many Native Americans were wrongfully revoked, suffered the pain of imprisonment and loss of freedom?  How many Native American families suffered because mothers, fathers, sons and daughters were incarcerated not because of wrongs they committed but because of Ron Alsbury's radical Mormon Theology?  How many Native Americans are still incarcerated and suffering not because of wrongs committed but because of Mormon Theology?  

Please, free our Native Americans that had revocations of probation and parole not because they committed crimes but because of Radical Mormon Theology.




 

 

 

 

Reform The Street Gang in Blue Overcrowding Montana Jails and Prisons

United States citizens are guaranteed certain rights through the Fifth and Fourth Amendments of the constitution.  We cannot legally be required to testify against ourselves and no one’s records or belongings may be legally searched or seized without cause.  American police are trained in methods of deception, intimidation and manipulation to abuse these guaranteed rights in the name of the law.

Have you ever heard this question, “Do you know why I stopped you?” “Do you know why I am questioning you?” If you make a guess at why you were stopped or being questioned, in the police prospective,  you confessed to a crime. If you answer  you “voluntarily” confessed.  The officer just got you to testify against yourself.  The cop is not there to serve you or engage in a friendly chat.  He or she is there fishing for an excuse to fine or arrest you and without any Miranda warning has just tricked you into confessing to a crime.

Now that you “voluntarily” confessed to a crime they can perform a warrantless search of  your person for their protection.  If you fail to comply after “voluntarily” confessing to a crime the implication is you have something to hide.  From the officer’s perspective if you don’t have something to hide you should be happy to be subjected to a search of your person, vehicle or home.  Due process has now been turned on its head as the cop has now put the burden on you to prove your innocence while implying that your failure to cooperate must be evidence of guilt.  Now the officer has disregarded and circumvented the Fourth Amendment on unreasonable searches.

Police routinely violate the Fifth and Fourth amendments knowing that cops are unlikely to face any punishment for doing so.  Usually all that happens is that any evidence obtained from illegal searches and “voluntary” confessions is the evidence is excluded from being allowed at trial.

The police can lie under oath, plant evidence, falsely charge people with resisting arrest, assaulting an officer or other illegal acts, knowing full well their fellow gang members – officers, prosecutors and judges- will almost never hold them accountable for their crimes.  The general public will almost always presume the gang members are truthful while the accused are guilty.

In an attempt to reform criminal justice laws in Montana we have allowed Montana Senate Bill 63 to become law.  This law facilitates plea-bargains so that illegally obtained evidence never has to face the light of trial. Yes, the officers, prosecutors and judges will never be held accountable under Senate Bill 63.

In an attempt to reform criminal justice laws in Montana we have allowed Senate Bill 60 to become law.  This law allows for presentence investigations to commence even before the accused has had a chance to prove their innocence.  Yes, under Senate Bill 60 the accused is guilty and must prove their innocence.

Before Montana can reform criminal justice laws, and reduce overcrowding in prisons and jails we have to reform law enforcement, judges and prosecutors.

Chief Justice Mike McGrath, Attorney General Tim Fox, Mike Batista, please set up a Commission on Law Enforcement, Judges and Prosecutors to study the tactics of deceit, intimidation and manipulations used to convict our citizens before passing any more useless legislation that continues to victimize our citizens.

 

 

 

Reform Law Enforcement and Prosecutors to Reduce Prison Overcrowding

To address the challenges of prison overcrowding, Chief Justice Mike McGrath, Attorney General Tim Fox (Montana's top cop), Montana Department of Corrections Director Mike Batista and others requested technical assistance from the Council of State Government Justice Center to use some abstract, collective behavior approach that was developed within a certain social group that will last a finite period of time. In other words, this too will pass. 

If Montana is really interested in reducing the number of criminal convictions we must diligently pursue the tactics used to convict defendants. One such tactic allows investigators to lie to the accused about the evidence against the accused. The concept of the lawful use of deception should not be a Montana value. Do we really want convictions based on lies and deception on the part of law enforcement? 

A person can be charged with a felony for lying to law enforcement yet we consistently allow law enforcement to lie to a defendant and their attorney. The idea that sometimes you have to resort to trickery to get a confession is paramount to saying the state has no case against the accused. If there is no case against the accused we should not be convicting them. You can try to justify this approach however being a good liar should not be a job requirement for law enforcement. Lying is a slippery slope. Where does the lying stop or does it stop? 

The second reform Montana needs is to adopt the current federal standard for Daubert, the standard set forth for expert witness testimony. Federal Rule 702 is as follows: 

RULE 702. TESTIMONY BY EXPERT WITNESSES A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education may testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise if: 
(a) The expert’s scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue; 
(b) The testimony is based on sufficient facts or data; 
(c) The testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods; and
(d) The expert has reliably applied the principles and methods to the facts of the case. 

In Montana Rule 702 reads as follows: 

Rule 702. Testimony by experts.  If scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will assist the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue, a witness qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education may testify thereto in the form of an opinion or otherwise. 

Montana does not require expert witnesses to use reliable principles and methods in conducting their examinations which brings us to expert witnesses such as the infamous and beleaguered James Blanco, a handwriting expert from California that purports to do work for the Montana Department of Justice on his curriculum vitae. In a deposition in a case, Blanco stated that one could hire an expert to "testify to the exact contrary" to another expert, because one "can pretty much get experts to say anything." See Southwell Decl. Ex. G. In yet another deposition, Blanco stated his findings would be different if he was working for the opposing side. See Edens vs Kennedy. The American Board of Forensic Document Examiners, the Southwest Association of Forensic Documents Examiners and the American Academy of Forensic Sciences determined that James Blanco had diminished confidence in forensic scientists and their disciplines. He is no longer allowed membership in their organizations, yet Montana allows his testimony because Montana does not require experts to use reliable methods. In other words, in Montana an expert can make any finding as requested by the Montana Department of Justice whether or not the finding is reliable. Whatever finding the Montana Department of Justice wants, Blanco will give it to them as will other experts hired by the Department of Justice. 

Chief Justice (former prosecutor for Lewis and Clark County and former Montana Attorney General) Mike McGrath knows this. Mike McGrath has hired James Blanco. Attorney General Tim Fox, Montana's top cop, knows Montana courts do not require reliable expert testimony. Montana Department of Corrections (former head of Montana Department of Justice Criminal Investigations) Mike Batista knows Montana does not require reliable expert witness testimony. Mike Batista has also hired James Blanco. 

I wonder why Mike McGrath, Tim Fox and Mike Batista, with the knowledge they have, don't start reforming laws pertaining to the concept of the lawful use of deception and Rule 702 that allows unreliable expert testimony? Oh wait, I know...they have all used these techniques and at least two of them have hired unreliable expert testimony in the form of James Blanco. 

Montana needs to decide which reform is better: (1) passing a bunch of bills based on some abstract, collective behavior approach that was developed within a certain social group that will last a finite period of time. Or (2) reforming the laws that convict Montana citizens by lies, treachery and subterfuge and hiring unreliable expert testimony.

Contact your legislator when you have made your decision.